Nyc knife laws reddit

Nyc knife laws reddit DEFAULT

I still remember the first knife I ever owned: it was a medium-sized Swiss Army Knife, made by Victorinox, called the Sportsman and it was given to me by my father. I had waited expectantly for that day ever since my brother received his first knife, a Leatherman, and was admittedly slightly disappointed when I saw my new possession’s size in comparison to what he had been given. I was confused; did my father think me unfit to handle a bigger blade? Maybe it had something to do with my brother lopping off the top of his finger while whittling a wine cork.

I didn’t have much use for a knife back then. The Sportsman’s tweezers saw more use than the knife blade, and I was thoroughly addled by the spiral tool affixed to one corner (a wine corkscrew). The knife spent most of its life in a drawer.

Years later, I recognized a need to carry a knife on a regular basis and stopped in at an REI while passing through Salt Lake City on my way from one coast to the other. I bought Gerber’s serrated Fast Draw, which, with a three-inch blade, isn’t a big knife by any means, but an upgrade over the Swiss Army nonetheless (and more formidable with a spring-loaded, assisted-opening mechanism). That knife became my daily companion, tasked with everything from opening letters at home to splitting pineapples on Costa Rica’s Sarapiqui river.

Jump ahead a handful of years, and I’m living in New York City, where an outdated law bans all “gravity knives” — folding knives that can be opened with inertia, like the flick of a wrist — as well as assisted opening switchblades, and my Gerber suddenly became quite illegal. I was forced to abandon it and search for a stand-in to fill the deep void it left.

When I stumbled across the James Brand’s Elko, memories of the Sportsman immediately brought forth preconceived ideas about the inadequacy of small pocket knives. Closed, the Elko is the size of a USB stick. Open, it’s just over inches, shorter than a standard pen. Not useful enough, I thought, keep looking.

Then, a few weeks later, I interviewed Ryan Coulter, the James Brand’s founder, about the design principles guiding the company’s aesthetic. He talked about minimalism, and a focus on quality, not quantity. And he used the Elko as a benchmark: “In some ways, it’s maybe the best example of modern minimal everyday carry that we’ve ever pulled off,” Coulter told me. “We really believe in this idea that the best knife for you is the one that you actually have with you. So the idea of having a knife that could go with your keys, that you can basically never forget, is a really important idea for us.”

I was convinced. An Elko — silver handle, stainless steel blade — has been affixed to my keyring in the months since. Its inch blade is Sandvik 12C27 steel, which is hard, corrosion-resistant and features a one-of-a-kind drop-point shape designed specifically for maxing out effectiveness with the smallest possible profile. Even the keyring loop on the Elko’s butt is designed for prying, scraping, twisting screws and opening bottles.

In fact, the best thing about the Elko is its size. No other knife, including the Sportsman, has ever gone as unnoticed in my pocket with my wallet and keys. It’s the type of item I forget about completely until the moment when I need it — a validation of good design in any product.

When I do move to a place with less antiquated knife laws, I’m not sure my old Gerber will find its way out of storage; it’ll sit in a drawer, next to the Sportsman, while the Elko stays attached to the keyring in my pocket.

The James Brand The Elko


This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at


New York Knife Laws Recipes

automatic-knives-in-ny-state-pageny-gun-forum image

 &#; New York - Penal Law Section A person is guilty of. criminal possession of a weapon in the fourth degree when: (1) He possesses any firearm, electronic dart gun, electronic stun. gun, gravity knife, switchblade knife, pilum ballistic knife, metal. knuckle knife…
User Interaction Count 50
Estimated Reading Time 8 mins
See details »

here-areinteractive-maps-that-tell-you-the-state-knife image

 &#; State knife laws can be as confusing and convoluted as State gun laws. It can be tough to know whether or not you're in compliance with the law concerning edged weapons . But, even though there are many definitions and legalities that vary from State to State, for most of us, carrying a knife …
Estimated Reading Time 2 mins
See details »

new-york-state-knife-laws-modern-survival-online image

 &#; It is impossible to overstate just how sinister New York’s knife laws are. New York has made the possession of any knife that is designed or adapted for use primarily as a weapon a crime, and the possession is presumptive evidence of intent to use said weapon unlawfully against another. It is a crime that will see you arrested and charged outright with no reservations, and if New York …
See details »

the-state-of-new-york-knife-law-youtube image

IMPORTANT NOTE: This is not legal advice. I also intentionally left out the hunting & fishing exemption to automatic knives because it is so vague and poorly
See details »

new-york-city-knife-laws-a-simple-cheat-sheet-with-all image

 &#; New York City knife laws states anyone under the age of 16 is not permitted to own and/or carry a “dangerous knife,” as defined by New York state law (N.Y. Penal Law &#; 05). The next clause in the New York state penal code makes it unlawful for anyone to possess a weapon on school grounds. New York City Knife Laws …
See details »

knife-law-new-york-knifehog-youtube image

In the state of New York, it’s legal to own and carry, either open or concealed, hunting knives, dirks, daggers or stilettos. The state of New York does not
See details »

new-york-state-knife-laws-a-guide-for-knife-carriers image

 &#; New York Penal Law (3) states: “The presence in an automobile, other than a stolen one or a public omnibus, of any firearm, defaced firearm, firearm silencer, bomb, bombshell, gravity knife, switchblade knife, dagger, dirk, stiletto, billy, …
See details »


Author Tom Marlowe
Estimated Reading Time 7 mins
See details »


 &#; Gravity Knife Ban Lifted In New York, Police Say They're 'Still Concerned' Jul 17, #12 Podmonkey A&M Magnum. U.S. Military. Monthly Shot Winner . Messages 19, Reaction score 25, Location Cambria co. PA. Willjr75 said: Didn’t they remove gravity from the law? Click to expand I think I read that yes. Still, I have a hard time imagining a cop getting in a twist over a …
User Interaction Count 26
Estimated Reading Time 7 mins
See details »


 &#; Check out the recipe from The New York Times, as well as several others from our archives. See if you can spot the differences between the recipes. Texas Sheet Cake. FOR THE CAKE: 1 cup/ grams
Author Claire Ballor
Phone ()
See details »


 &#; The problem starts with the definition of “Gravity Knife” from the New York State Penal Law. Sec. (5) states that a Gravity Knife is any knife that can be opened by gravity or the application of centrifugal force. What the latter part means is that if the knife can be “flicked” opened (centrifugal force), it is illegal to possess. It gets more complicated if you think that a
Estimated Reading Time 2 mins
See details »


New York State Knife Laws American Knife & … 7 hours ago Get All . Knife New York City – Administrative Code &#; , knives must be concealed and any blade must be less than 4 inches. Also note the Transit Authority Code mentioned above. Rochester – &#; , Prohibits carry of pointed instruments other than a pocketknife with no blade more than 3 inches in length.
See details »


Knife Laws by State Certain knives are used mostly for protection, for hunting, and for handyman work. Owning a knife is not illegal within the United States. However, each state has different regulations on the types of knives that people can have. They also …
From taccom
See details »


New York City Knife Laws: A Simple Cheat Sheet With All . Law (9 days ago) Written into a New York City ordinance, a resident or visitor to the city is allowed to carry a knife that measures fewer than four inches. “It shall be unlawful for any person to carry on his or her person or have in such person’s possession, in any public place, street, or park any knife which has a blade length
See details »


 &#; New York Knife Laws June 18, Below you will find the actual text of the New York State Penal Code and the New York City Municipal Code related to knives. Included are some notes to clarify how the laws are interpreted. The key issue is that until such time as Knife Rights prevails in its federal civil rights lawsuit against New York City and District Attorney Vance, it doesn’t matter
See details »


Know The Law: Knife Laws In New York Before Buying. Before purchasing a penknife in any state in the USA, you require to understand before hand whether owning one is legal or prohibited in your state and what are the laws, rules or regulations governing these knives. It is essential to your compliance with the law and your duty as a law abiding person to do so prior to you select purchasing
See details »


Law says 4 inches and under for a knife but to be safe, your better off just carrying an SAK or an slipjoint. Anything Kershaw or black would be considered an "switchblade" or "gravity knife". 9. level 1. Quietmerch &#; 4y. Just don't. I lived in nyc for 4 years for school (where I was actually issued a knife).
See details »


 &#; Pocket Knife Restrictions in NYC; Federal Gun Laws for Convicted Felons; Pepper Spray Laws in Texas; Knives are both dangerous items and everyday necessities for cooks, hunters, fisherman and even warehouse workers who deal with endless streams of cardboard boxes each day. However, the Criminal Code of Canada does outlaw some types of knives, and different police departments and …
See details »


New York knife laws? I'm looking to buy an EDC knife, but I'm having trouble navigating the laws here. I live in Upstate New York, so NYC's insane laws aren't a problem, but as far as I can tell New York considers any knife with any sort of assisted opening device at all to be a switchblade.
See details »


The knife possession law of New York has stated the illegal knives thoroughly and these are quite a big number. But still there remain some knives legal. They are, Knives that are disguised under pen, cane, lipstick or belt buckles etc. are legal; Dirks, daggers, stilettos and other double-edged knives are legal unless they are intended to be used unlawfully against one another. Bowie knives
See details »


New York State Knife Laws American Knife & … 7 hours ago Get All . Knife Major New York Cities with Knife Restrictive Ordinances: Albany – None noted. Buffalo – &#; , Prohibits open carry or display of weapons including knives on city-owned property.New York City – Administrative Code &#; , knives must be concealed and any blade must be less than 4 inches.
See details »


North Carolina Knife Laws American Knife and Tool … Law (3 days ago) North Carolina law, &#; , restricts the concealed carry of any bowie knife, dirk, dagger, razor, or “other deadly weapon of like kind,” except when one is on his own premises.There is an “ordinary pocketknife” exception which does not extend to some of the location-based restrictions such as schools.
See details »


 &#; The "gravity knife" ban was part of New York State law so it applied in NYC and outside of NYC as well, I heard they took "gravity knife" off the list of prohibited dangerous weapons this year. So anyway, the gravity knife thing where the police would take a locking folder and use inertia to get the blade to open with a "wrist flick" and then nab you, that was all of NY state not just NYC. In
See details »


 &#; I live in upstate in Elmira, New York. I often go down to Pennsylvania as much as i live in NY. I am now just recently acquiring larger knives. Two knives specifically i would like to find out if i can carry them without trouble is : KA-BAR Full Size US Marine Corps Fighting Knife
See details »


See details »


 &#; New York law defines “switchblade knife” as follows: ‘Switchblade knife’ means any knife which has a blade which opens automatically by hand pressure applied to a button, spring or other device in the handle of the knife. (&#; ) In the case of People v Berrezueta 31 N.Y.3d (), a knife described as having “a spring-loaded portion of the blade of the knife protruding from
See details »

  1. Tm shop pokemon shield
  2. Lewiston maine weather
  3. Resident evil 2 password
  4. 1200 ninja kawasaki
  5. Jean paul saxophones

Gravity Knife Ban Lifted In New York, Police Say They&#;re &#;Still Concerned&#;

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) — The ban on gravity knives in New York has been lifted, and while it’s good news for many workers and artisans, it’s creating a new problem for some law enforcement officers.

The folding knives have a blade that opens up using the flick of the wrist, and they’re commonly used by construction workers, day laborers and artisans.

READ MORE: Gabby Petito Died By Strangulation, Wyoming Coroner Finds

The knives are widely sold, but up until now, they were illegal to carry in New York.

WEB EXTRA – Mayor de Blasio and the NYPD discuss the lifted ban on gravity knives and more:

“If you could buy them anywhere, why not?” Rafael Morales said.

Morales runs Metropolitan Hardware on 11th Avenue in Manhattan.

“A lot of people buy them for work. They use them every day. You know, minor jobs around the house. I don’t see what’s wrong with them,” he told CBS2’s Alice Gainer.

But the New York Police Department calls them “rapidly deployable combat knives.”

It opposed the lift on the ban, with officials saying there have been 1, slashings and stabbings in New York so far this year.

Gravity knives (Credit: CBS2)

READ MORE: New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy, Republican Challenger Jack Ciattarelli Trade Jabs In Last Debate Before Election Day

At Tuesday’s New York Police Department press conference on crime statistics, however, officials were unable to say specifically if gravity knives were used in any of those slashings.

The bill signed Thursday removes references of “gravity knives” as a dangerous weapon.

This was the third time the Legislature sought to remove criminal sanctions associated with possessing the knives.

FLASHBACK:Assemblyman Launches New Push To Reform Gravity Knife Law

Gov. Andrew Cuomo vetoed similar bills twice, but this time, he signed, saying “the legal landscape has changed.”

In March, a federal court ruling found the previous ban to be unconstitutional, reasoning that the existing law could result in “discriminatory enforcement” and was vague.

The Legal Aid Society issued a report on caseload data for gravity knife arrests and prosecutions between January and June of

It says New Yorkers of color are targeted. There were gravity knife arrests arraigned by Legal Aid in the first six months of and 88% of people arrested for gravity knife possession are people of color.

MORE NEWS: Car Crashes Into Brooklyn Funeral Home, Police Say Driver May Have Been Involved In Carjacking

The NYPD commissioner says it’s still illegal to have a gravity knife in the subway.


There are hundreds of reasons not to buy knives from Amazon.

Not only is there a possibility you&#;d get a fake knife but it is also crippling small businesses like ours. (Oh, and Amazon also treat employees like crap.)

And now Amazon has started preventing law-abiding citizens from buying and shipping knives to certain states.

To be honest, I&#;m not entirely sure how long this has been going on or how widespread it is, but a customer brought it to our attention. Here&#;s the lowdown.

A customer tried to purchase a Kershaw Link from Amazon and have it shipped somewhere in Long Island, New York. However, upon checkout, they got a notice saying the item &#;can&#;t be shipped to your selected address.&#; So, he wisely bought the folder from Knife Depot instead.


New York & Massachusetts Restricted

After I did a little digging, I found one of the earliest incidence of a restricted knife purchase was in on a forum post at NY Firearms. That was chocked up to a possible error.

The issue didn&#;t seem to start gaining more attention until late when someone posted on Blade Forums about a knife purchase not going through. However, this one was from Massachusetts.

I did my own little experiment trying to buy and ship a Kershaw Cryo G to an address in New York City.

This is what I got:

I thought it could just be because the address was in New York City so I picked an address in Central New York (Syracuse, to be exact). The same result.

Because I had heard the same thing about Massachusetts, I tried to buy and ship the Cryo G to an address there.  It was also a no-go.

I wanted to figure out how far this extended, so I did a few experiments in neighboring states. Connecticut and New Jersey were not restricted.

I didn&#;t do every single state in the country, but it seems like New York and Massachusetts are the only ones affected.

Assisted & Some Manual Openers Restricted

My next investigation was to find out which knives are affected. It was obvious that Amazon appeared to be targeting assisted-opening knives as evident by the restriction on the Link and Cryo. I tested the theory on some of the assisted openers from other brands like Gerber.

The Gerber Outrigger, which features an assisted-opening blade, was also restricted.

So I threw some softballs and went for the Fallkniven U4, which has a small lockback blade, and the Gerber LST. Both knives were OK to ship to New York and Massachusetts.

But when I tried to buy the Kershaw Skyline, a manual-opening knife with a flipper, it too was restricted.

Other Kershaw knives like the Pub and Shuffle were fine, however.

It seems like Amazon is specifically targeting assisted openers and some flippers because a Kershaw Emerson CQC-6K (a manual opener with a Wave feature) is A-OK but a Kershaw Chill (a manual opener with a flipper) is not.

Someone on Reddit asked Kershaw&#;s customer service if they were aware of this. Here is part of their reply:

Thank you for your email, we sincerely appreciate your interest in Kershaw knives! We apologize that you have had difficulties in completing recent purchases from Amazon for our products. We are aware of the issue and we are working with our vendor relations team at Amazon to have this corrected. In the meantime, we are asking our customers who reach out & are willing, to follow the attached instructions on filling a ‘customer service issue’ with Amazon. There have been no changes on our end, no new laws introduced, and we are just as concerned as our consumers with the restriction that Amazon has put in place regarding the State of NY.


We hope this information helps! Thank you again for reaching out to us, we are hopeful that if enough consumers voice their concerns it will lead to a positive outcome with Amazon! Have a great day!

So this raises the question: What the heck is going on?

Why is Amazon Doing This?

The fact that Amazon is restricting the shipment of both assisted openers and some manual openers is beyond bizarre.

Amazon has a policy on restricted items, which is kind of confusing. Under examples of permitted listings, it says &#;Spring-assisted or assisted-opening knives that do not automatically extend.&#; However, under examples of prohibited listings, it says &#;Spring-loaded knives.&#;

The assisted openers are clearly allowed under the rules but &#;spring-loaded knives&#; is kind of a strange term to use for prohibited knives, especially since there is already a line about automatic knives or switchblades.

As Kershaw noted, there have been no new laws in New York or Massachusetts that would lead to such a restriction.

New York City has had some troubles with classifying tons of legal knives as gravity knives under a vague and antiquated law. It&#;s possible Amazon didn&#;t want to get in trouble with the city so it restricts shipping similar knives to the entire state. However, that doesn&#;t explain the restriction on Massachusetts.

Neither state outright bans assisted openers but there is also no statewide preemption law so it&#;s possible some municipalities banned the knives.

I reached out to Amazon, but I only got a roundabout reply that did not directly address my question. I&#;ll update if I receive an actual response.

As of now it remains unclear why Amazon is doing what it&#;s doing or how wide the problem extends. However, let this be yet another gentle reminder to get your knives at a dedicated knife shop like Knife Depot.


Knife laws reddit nyc

The ‘Gravity Knife’ Led to Thousands of Questionable Arrests. Now It’s Legal.

Black and Latino men had often been charged under New York’s unusual ban on the knives, which are opened with a flick of the wrist.

The Manhattan district attorney, Cyrus Vance, has said that the ban on gravity knives has enhanced public safety and pushed lawmakers to keep it.

Over the past 60 years, tens of thousands of black and Latino New Yorkers have been arrested for carrying so-called gravity knives — small, easy-to-access blades that are used by everyone from stagehands to steelworkers.

But on Thursday, in another demonstration of New York’s surging progressive wing’s influence, Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo ended that practice, signing a bill to remove such knives from the category of “deadly weapons,” a designation reserved for guns, daggers and switchblades, and allow their possession.

New York law defines a gravity knife as a knife with the blade in the handle that can be opened with a one‐handed flick of the wrist. They differ from switchblades, which use a spring to propel the blade into an open position automatically with the push of a button.

But critics of the old law said common folding knives and tradespeople’s knives could be deemed gravity knives if an officer was able to flick them open with centrifugal force, and some people had been arrested for possessing ordinary knives they needed for work.

In signing the bill — passed unanimously by the Democratic-led Legislature — the governor cited a March decision from the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, which found the gravity-knife law “presents a high risk of arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement” and was “unconstitutionally vague.”

The decision was immediately hailed by public defenders and other legal advocates.

The ban and the way it was enforced constituted “one of the most discriminatory policing practices in our state,” said Tina Luongo, a lawyer with the Legal Aid Society, which issued a report showing the racial disparity in the way the law was carried out.

“For far too long, the N.Y.P.D. exploited the gravity-knife ban to drive up arrest numbers at the expense of our clients,” she said.

Gravity knives have been outlawed in New York since , when the State Legislature banned a Nazi-era weapon known as “the Luftwaffe gravity knife,” according to Martin J. LaFalce, another Legal Aid lawyer.

The decision by the governor came after seven years of lobbying by lawmakers and two previous vetoes of similar legislation by Mr. Cuomo in the face of opposition from law enforcement and elected officials.

The bill’s signing on Thursday marked the latest setback for the state’s prosecutors, traditionally a powerful political force. In March, Mr. Cuomo approved legislation to create a commission to investigate prosecutorial misconduct. That commission has been challenged by the District Attorneys Association of the State of New York, which also had lobbied in the past against lifting the gravity-knife ban.

Prosecutors have also been adapting to recent changes in the state’s discovery law and its bail system, both of which were hailed as major victories by advocates for criminal justice reform, particularly in regard to treatment of minority groups.

The association held tight to its position on gravity knives on Friday.

“We continue to believe that gravity knives are dangerous weapons which do not belong in densely populated areas,” said Albany County District Attorney David Soares, the association’s president. “The governor and State Legislature have made it clear they feel differently.”

In a statement after the bill was signed, the New York Police Department said it had “opposed the legislation because gravity knives are in reality rapidly deployable combat knives.”

“There have been more than 1, stabbings and slashings in New York City so far this year,” the department said, adding, “The public should also be aware that the possession of gravity knives in the New York City subway system remains illegal.”

The Assembly sponsor of the gravity knife bill, Dan Quart, a Democrat from Manhattan, said that the bill signing was a clear victory over “a deep problem in the penal law” and the policies of Cyrus R. Vance Jr., the borough’s district attorney.

“It’s impossible not to look at the arrest and prosecution numbers in Manhattan, under Cy Vance, and not see a deep disproportionate racial impact,” Mr. Quart said.

A spokesman for Mr. Vance, Danny Frost, struck a conciliatory tone. “We continue to believe that gravity knives make our streets and subways less safe,” Mr. Frost said in a statement on Friday. “But we respect that state lawmakers have a different view and we are moving swiftly to implement this legislative change.”

Mr. Quart said that a gravity knife “doubles as a work tool,” and indeed, the Legal Aid Society’s report found that such knives are easily found at scores of hardware stores.

Eric Correa, a year-old New York City parks department employee who was arrested on charges of possessing a knife last year, said he bought his at a uniform shop in Jamaica, Queens.

Mr. Correa said in an interview that he used it to clean his weed-whacker at work, as well as to open cans of paint. But when an officer noticed it clipped to his pants on the subway, Mr. Correa was arrested.

“It felt like maybe it was a quick collar,” said Mr. Correa, who is part Latino and part African-American. The charges against him were eventually dismissed in exchange for community service, but he lost time at work.

In previous vetoes, Mr. Cuomo had acknowledged the tension “between protecting public safety and addressing an absurd contradiction in existing commercial and enforcement practices.”

But he wrote on Thursday: “While I remain aware of the cautious community voices, I cannot veto a bill passed by the Legislature to address a decided constitutional infirmity.”

Mr. Cuomo added: “I remain confident that our law enforcement community will continue to keep our communities safe by pursuing anyone who uses, or attempts to use, one of these knives in an unlawful manner.”

The State Of New York Knife Law

New York is one of the most densely populated states in the United States, with nearly 20 million residents calling it home.

That being said, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that it also has some of the highest crime rates in the entire nation, although not quite the worst.

New York is essentially a diehard liberal state, in just about every aspect.

Of course, what this means is that self-defense weapons often receive harsh limitations and guidelines as to what the citizens can and cannot use or own.

This in turn calls for the citizens of New York to be creative in what they can use legally.

Luckily, firearms are legal in the state of New York. However, there are quite a few requirements to do so legally.

In this article, I’ll also cover many other used self-defense weapons that are legal in New York that are much easier to own than firearms without running through the hoops of law. Let’s take a look.

Legal Self Defense Weapons in New York


Many Regulations


I sat on this question for quite a while. Trying to determine the best answer was hard. With that said, however, I’m going to make a recommendation.

New York requires a large amount of regulations to follow,  such as the amount of ammunition the weapon can hold, the length of the weapon, or what type of accessories can be attached.

Tricky Licensing Process

One of the requirements for the license is essentially their “judgement of your character.”

This essentially means that they could easily deny you a permit, simply by the way you looked at them.

I’ve looked at this online, and they will drag the licensing process out for months for absolutely no reason, in hopes that you give up.

Through my research, there are actually quite a few weapons that are legal in the state of New York.

What’s Legal?

However, each weapon has a very unique set of regulations to be strictly followed at all times.

A few of these weapons include: long rifles, pistols and shotguns. It’s also illegal to stop somewhere within the city while the weapon is on your person.

This is where I had to stop for a second to determine it’s worthiness, but the benefits that it will provide you, particularly at home, makes it all the more worth it.

Better To Have It

I’d rather have it and not need it, versus the contrary of not having it and needing it. Firearms are tricky to obtain and use legally in the state of New York.

For this reason, I nearly omitted this from the article. Despite this, it’s definitely possible to do so legally.

You’ll just need to follow the laws and regulations properly. I’m going to cover the different laws, regulations and the ‘how to’ further into the article, which will cover the basics for you.

Also, due to the sheer amount of laws and regulations in the state of New York, I recommend that you visit this Wikipedia page.

Doing so will allow you to view each requirement in the state of New York; because there is definitely a huge amount of them.


The Benefits


Carrying a knife is a very good way to defend yourself, as long as you know how to use it and how to avoid the target grabbing it from you.

I’ve carried a knife often, and it’s nice knowing that it’s there if I need it. In the state of New York, knives are, in fact, legal.

There are quite a few laws that you must follow, however. These include the types of knives, size and use, for example. Let’s cover the specifications.

The Law: Basics

The Type: This law had me particularly surprised, mostly at the sheer amount of what isn’t legal.

Fortunately for us, I’ve found a few that are. These include stilettos, hunting knives and gravity knives, to name a few.

The Size: This is where the determining factor between jail and freedom comes into the picture.

New York is extremely hard on this law, so make sure you follow it. Their maximum length of the blade comes in at a whopping 4” long.

My Recommendations

Is it enough to do damage? Yes, but it’s not the most appealing size, that’s for sure.

I was surprised when I looked a little deeper into the ‘fine print’ of the knife laws. You should know that many knives are unable to be legally used in ‘self-defense’ within the city limits of NYC, one of those being the gravity knife.

A knife size and type that I’d recommend would be a hunting knife with a blade no longer than 4” (per New York restrictions) that has no capability to fold. Check here for an in-depth review of many great knives!

Sketchy Wording

In many places, wearing them with the intent of ‘self-defense’ against another human is illegal.

This just means that you’ll want to be a little creative as to what your “real” use of the weapon is actually for.

If you’d like more information about what’s legal and what’s not, then please visit the AKTI website for a more detailed look.

Check out this article written by one of our survival professionals for a few great in-depth reviews of great knives, many which are legal in New York.

Pepper Spray

Is It Worthy To Carry?

I carry pepper spray on my person and regularly recommend it to friends and family. It’s one of the most veritable self defense weapons, in my opinion.

I say this because it can be kept just about everywhere; not to mention it’s small, compact and packs a punch.

With pepper spray, you essentially spray a substance into the target’s eyes, leaving them nearly blinded and in severe pain for minutes, which is enough time to flee and get help.

Is Pepper Spray legal in NYC?

The legality of pepper spray in New York is pretty simple. If it’s labeled as a self-defense item, it’s legal. It must be pocket-sized, though, and purchased only within the state of New York.

It must also have a number somewhere on the bottle that returns the caller back to a self-defense course.

To read more about these laws, visit the LegalBeagle. If you think purchasing one may benefit you, check out this in-depth review of Devil Juice Pepper Spray.

Tactical Pen

Many Uses

This is definitely one of the favorites of mine on this list. For one reason, they’re extremely low profile.

This means that you’ll unlikely grab any unwanted attention in public with it, particularly if it’s visible to those around you.

Another reason I love them is due to their wide spectrum of use. Oftentimes, they have the ability to write, crack open cans, break glass and provide all types of other uses.

They Inflict Serious Damage

They’re a bit bigger than regular pens, but not by much. Nonetheless, tactical pens can, if you allow it, inflict serious damage; essentially as dangerous as you’d need.

It should be noted that it could be snatched from you during a hand-to-hand fight.

You’ll just have to make sure that when it’s time to use it, you hit them on the first throw.

We’ve already taken it upon ourselves to review the Strike Pen, which is honestly a great pick for most situations. They’re perfectly legal in New York too, according to their federal websites.

Baseball Bat

Zero Regulations

I know, a baseball bat? Surprisingly, I think it’s a good recommendation. Particularly for home defense; although it could be used as defense while in your vehicle too.

I wanted to add something that could inflict severe damage, yet something that was also legally owned and obtained without any licenses or laws to jump through.

Adequate Protection

Baseball bats can inflict deadly damage, as long as you use them right. You could practice outside first, but to say it would leave the target in pain is an understatement.

A single tap to the head and he’s down for the count. Yes, I know it’s not versatile in the sense of a casual self defense weapon to carry down the sidewalk; that wouldn’t be a good idea, obviously.

But if you want something easily obtainable and damage inflicting, a baseball bat is a good way to go.

They’re perfectly legal, as long as you don’t attach any crazy accessories to it like spikes or anything. (Do not put spikes on your baseball bat!)

Honorable Mentions

Martial Arts

Weapons Only Get You So Far

Weapons are a great way to protect yourself, but they can only get you so far. You may also find yourself unable to carry such a weapon on your person at some point.

Due to the extreme weapon restrictions of New York, I’ve decided to mention Martial Arts. These can include anything from Boxing, MMA, Taekwondo, Karate or Judo to name a few.

Think Longterm 

Many of these Martial Arts not only teach you how to disable your target but also teach you how to safely grab a weapon such as a gun or knife away from your opponent without injuring yourself.

This is especially useful up close of course, but it’s a skill that once learned, will stick with you for many years.

Frequently asked Questions

How Do I Obtain A Firearm License in New York?

The First Step

Firearm licenses are definitely obtainable in the state of New York; but don’t think it’ll be an easy process.

First you’ll need to contact your local sheriff’s office; they’ll be able to either start the application process or tell you where to go to do so, such as the court clerk office.

The Annoying Part

The fees are roughly $ to apply. You’ll need lots of legal documents too, including your birth certificate, state I.D, proof of citizenship and many others.

Keep in mind, pistols are only allowed concealed permits. Once you’ve applied, expect to wait 4 months before you are given the license.

During this wait however, you’ll likely be required to do an interview to assess your cognitive and character health.

The Detailed Information

It’s not that complicated, just a few simple questions to determine your reasons, for example.

This process is very similar for long arm rifles and shotguns. Check the New York’s .gov website out for more detailed information regarding firearm licenses.

Are There Any Requirements To Own A Firearm in New York?

Background Check

Firearms definitely have quite a few requirements that must be met in any state, especially New York. In order to apply, you first need to pass a background check.

If you have a felony, or any violent crimes on your record, you’ll immediately be disqualified.

After this process, you’ll be required to do an interview with the state to determine your mental health and reasons for wanting a firearm.

Fingerprints & Age + Character

They have the discretion to disqualify you for mannerisms even, so make sure you’re presentable and well-characterized during the interview.

Fingerprints are another requirement that must be met before licensing approval. Keep in mind, you’ll need to be at least 21 years of age to be eligible for a license in New York. It’s not terribly difficult, but it definitely takes time; so be patient.

Which Weapon Would Be Best For Me?

Determining What’s Best

In order to answer the question properly, you must ask yourself what you’re using it for exactly.

Firearms are obviously the most reliable in terms of protection, but are limited in use in New York.

If you want something that provides the most protective result, yet comes with a slew of restrictions (such as the requirement to have firearms unloaded during city travel) then Firearms are a great choice.

There are still plenty of other useful scenarios for firearms in New York.

Less Regulated Self Defense Weapons

Baseball bats provide brute force deviation if used properly, but are not versatile. Pepper spray is extremely versatile, yet mainly induces main and very temporary disability.

Strike pens provide excellent protection and are very well hidden, even on plain sight.

Knives however, inflict nearly as much deadly force as firearms, but require essentially hand to hand combat, and you risk it being snatched away from you.

They each have their own pros and cons, which is why we recommend having one for each situation. Firearms for long range, and the handhelds for short range (and much less regulations!).

What guns are legal in NY?

A lot of guns are legal in New York State which are not legal in other States across the USA. In New York you can own or possess a long gun, including shotguns and rifles, without requiring a permit or a license.

It is also possible to own a pistol in New York State, but to be able to carry this type of gun you will have to obtain a permit for the weapon in order to own it legally. The main reason behind you needing a permit to carry a pistol, but not a rifle or shotgun, is because of concealment.

It is easy to conceal a pistol and for others to not know that you are carrying it, but this is almost impossible with a long gun which explains the difference in laws between the two types of firearm. But note, laws differ for New York City.

Are brass knuckles illegal in NY State?

Yes, brass knuckles are illegal in New York State. This includes both metal and plastic brass knuckles, so if you are seen possessing or wearing them anywhere across New York State then you could face prosecution.

Brass knuckles are a ‘self-defense’ weapon that fits to your hand. The device comes with holes for you to slot your fingers through and a metal or plastic bar that then covers your knuckles to create more of an impact should your fist come into contact with anybody or anything.

Traditionally, these weapons were constructed using brass, hence their name, however over time they have evolved, and they are now made with a variety of different metals and plastics. Brass knuckles can be bought, and they can also be made, but if you are found possessing any then you could face legal consequences.

Are collapsible batons legal in NY?

No. Batons are illegal in New York.

Can I shoot a pistol in NY without a permit?

No, in order to shoot a pistol or possess a pistol, anywhere in New York State, you will need to obtain a permit for that firearm.

While you do not need to have a permit in order to own or shoot a long gun, smaller guns, like pistols, do require a permit under NY law due to the element of concealment that they offer.

While there is nothing stopping you from shooting a pistol without a permit in New York State, if you are caught shooting it, or simply caught holding that gun you could get in trouble.

If you were caught possessing a pistol by an official then they will likely request that you bring forward the permit for such a weapon, if you do not have one then you could find yourself caught up in some legal trouble.

Can I open carry a long gun in NY?

The laws surrounding open carrying in New York are a bit blurry. It is clearly illegal to openly carry a handgun anywhere in New York State, but there does not appear to be any legal restriction that would prevent you from open carrying your long gun in New York.

Unlike handguns, under NY Law you do not need a permit in order to own, possess, carry, or shoot a long gun.

Mainly due to the fact that long guns cannot be easily concealed, while handguns can. So while the laws surrounding the open carry of guns in NY seem to be blurry, it appears that you will require a permit in order to carry a concealed handgun in public, but there doesn’t seem to be anything preventing you from open carrying your long gun in this State of America.

Can you own an AR15 in New York State?

Just like the laws surrounding open carrying in New York, the laws surrounding assault rifles are very unclear. There is a list of weapons that are banned in New York State, and the AR15 (just like many other ArmaLite Rifles) does not appear on this list, but does this mean that they are legal?

An AR is named after the company that first designed the platform, and they are a type of assault rifles that have a selective fire option. These are commonly available in many US states, but New York is among the few that are more restrictive to their gun availability.

While the AR is not necessarily banned by name, only certain variants are legal under the SAFE Act (). Guns that fall under the SAFE act purchased before January 15, , and were registered with state police before April 15, , are legal to own in New York.

So, if you have owned and had your AR registered before this date, then your gun is technically legal. However, newer ARs than this are not available to civilians of New York State.

Is NY a stand your ground State?

Stand your ground laws differ all across America with different States implementing different laws and regulations. In New York, you have the right to protect yourself and your home and can do this through the use of self-defense.

When it comes to self-defense, a lot of people are reliant on weapons and firearms but are you allowed to use them to protect yourself and your property in NY?

Yes, you can as NY has laws which state that a person can use ‘deadly physical force’ upon another individual if they believe that that individual has the potential to do something that could cause deadly physical harm to themselves.

This means that in New York you are allowed to use physical force to protect yourself and your home, rather than your first mode of defense being retreat as it is in some other States.

How many rounds can you carry in NY?

Every State has a restriction on the amount of rounds that you can carry for your firearm at any one time. In NY this limit stands at 7 rounds.

So when you are out in public with your firearm anywhere in New York State it is illegal to carry a magazine that contains more than 7 bullets inside of it. However, there are some exemptions to this rule.

For example, if you are at a shooting range or at a competition that is recognized by the National Rifle Association then the number of bullets that you can carry in a magazine is 10 instead of 7.

On your own land, you are able to carry more rounds than this, but ensure that you are definitely on your land at all times and that you do not stray onto public property.

Can I open carry on my property in NY?

On your own land you can open carry your gun, however you will still be bound by State laws.

This means that you can open carry your long gun without requiring a permit or license for the weapon, but if you want to open carry a pistol or handgun you will need to obtain a permit for that firearm.

However, you need a permit to legally own a handgun in New York State, so if you own a handgun the chances are that you will already have a permit. If you are able to produce this permit when requested then you are allowed to open carry your handgun in your own property in NY.

If you own a long gun then you will not need a permit to be able to open carry on your property as you do not need a permit to own a long gun in New York State.


When looking at the different weapon laws in New York, I consider myself lucky to have such relaxed laws here in the southern part of the United States.

New York has some of the strictest weapon laws in the country, but it’s definitely possible to acquire a few useful items.

Items that would inflict enough damage to a life threatening individual, to make them rethink their entire life and every decision they’ve ever made. As long as you follow the state laws and regulations, you’ll be just fine.

You don’t ‘always’ need a bazooka to defend yourself, so these weapons will likely be satisfactory for most any dangerous scenario you find yourself in.

Written by Bryan Rucker

Brian Rucker has spent his entire life participating in essentially all things wildlife. His concern grew astronomically during the previous tensions between the United States and other nations. He also has grown a substantial interest in survival and sustainability due to the current shape of the world over the years. He believes that preparation triumphs all things. Read more of Bryan's articles.


You will also like:

In New York City, you can go to prison with a flick of a police officer’s wrist.


A state law banning so-called gravity knives, a cousin of the switchblade, has been twisted by New York City police to include almost any kind of foldable knife that can be opened with the flick of the wrist. Even some old and worn down pocket knives fit that description when in the hands of a cop who is skilled at flicking open knives and is looking to make an arrest. That broad interpretation has landed about 60, people—the vast majority black and Latino—in court since


The city has even gone after retailers such as Home Depot, which sell utility knives commonly used by handymen. The home improvement giant was forced to hand over more than 1, knives it had in stock in its New York City stores and forfeit the proceeds of four years of knife sales, according to The Village Voice.


Some are now fighting back. Knife Rights, an owners’ group similar to the National Rifle Association, and Native Leather, a retailer, and two defendants in knife cases have sued (pdf) the city, claiming the way it applies the knife law is unconstitutionally vague.  “Specifically, defendants have applied the law to any folding knife—even ones ‘designed to resist opening from the closed position’—if it would be possible for some person to open the knife by means of a wrist‐flicking motion. Plaintiffs argue that a person in possession of a common folding knife, particularly one that the person himself is unable to open with a wrist flick, cannot be expected to know that his possession is criminal because some as‐yet‐unidentified person may be able to flick open the knife,” according to the suit.


“There’s simply no way for an honest citizen to know how to comply with the law the way the city is enforcing it,” Knife Rights president Doug Ritter told the Voice. “That is the very essence of ‘vagueness,’ and that precedent is very well established in law.”


The state judiciary is on record as saying the law is wrongly applied on a regular basis, and Democrats in the state Congress have spent years trying to change the law.


A federal appeals court ruled Tuesday that Knife Rights has no standing to sue, but the case will now be sent back to a lower court for the retailer and two other plaintiffs to proceed with their suit.

-Steve Straehley


To Learn More:

Constitutional Challenge to Controversial NYC Knife Law Moves Ahead (by Jon Campbell, Village Voice)

NYC Knife Law Challenge Is Revived by U.S. Appeals Court (by Jonathan Stempel, Reuters)

Knife Rights, et al, v. Cyrus Vance, Jr. (pdf)

How A ’50s-Era New York Knife Law Has Landed Thousands in Jail (by Jon Campbell, Village Voice)


8067 8068 8069 8070 8071